Skip to main content

The Rising Impact of Independent Insurance Agencies: A Look at the Latest Big “I” Report

By June 29, 2024July 1st, 2024No Comments
School Insurance - Smiling Young Schoolgirl Walking past Lockers with a Backpack and Carrying Books with Classmates Following behind and Blurred in the Background


The insurance industry has been evolving rapidly, and recent reports highlight the significant role of independent insurance agencies in shaping the sector’s future. According to the latest Big “I” report, independent agencies placed 62% of all property/casualty premiums in 2023. This milestone underscores the growing importance of independent agents as trusted advisors in personal and commercial insurance lines. As an independent agency, Vantage Point Risk is proud to be part of this dynamic landscape, offering our clients unparalleled choice and expertise.

The Big “I” Report: Key Findings

The Big “I” (Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America) report provides an in-depth analysis of independent insurance agencies’ performance and market share. Here are some of the key findings from the 2023 report:

  1. Market Share Growth: Independent agencies placed 62% of property/casualty premiums, reflecting a steady growth trend over the past few years. This increase indicates clients’ value on personalized service and tailored insurance solutions.

  2. Commercial Lines Dominance: Independent agencies dominate the commercial lines market, accounting for many business insurance placements. This sector’s complexity and need for customized coverage make independent agents a preferred choice for businesses.

  3. Personal Lines Expansion: While commercial lines remain a stronghold, independent agencies make substantial inroads into the personal lines market. The report highlights a growing consumer preference for independent agents who can offer a wider range of options and unbiased advice.

  4. Digital Transformation: Independent agencies’ adoption of digital tools and technologies has been critical to their success. From advanced quoting systems to customer relationship management (CRM) platforms, technology is enhancing the efficiency and reach of independent agents.

Why Independent Agencies Are Thriving

Several factors contribute to the rising influence of independent insurance agencies:

  1. Personalized Service: Unlike captive agents representing a single insurer, independent agents can access multiple carriers. This allows them to provide clients with various options and tailor policies to meet specific needs. At Vantage Point Risk, we pride ourselves on our ability to offer customized solutions that fit each client’s unique requirements.

  2. Expertise and Advice: Independent agents are known for their deep industry knowledge and expertise. They serve as trusted advisors, helping clients navigate the complexities of insurance coverage and claims. This advisory role is particularly valuable in commercial lines, where businesses require specialized coverage and risk management strategies.

  3. Community Focus: Many independent agencies are deeply rooted in their local communities. This local presence allows them to build strong client relationships and offer personalized service that large, impersonal insurers cannot match. Vantage Point Risk’s commitment to community engagement is a cornerstone of our business philosophy.

  4. Flexibility and Choice: By representing multiple carriers, independent agents can provide clients greater flexibility and choice. This competitive advantage enables them to find the best coverage at competitive rates. Our access to diverse insurance providers ensures we can always find the right fit for our clients.

The Role of Technology in Independent Agencies

Technology has played a pivotal role in the success and growth of independent insurance agencies. Here are some ways technology is transforming the industry:

  1. Quoting and Comparison Tools: Advanced quoting systems allow independent agents to quickly and accurately compare policies from different insurers. This capability saves time and ensures that clients receive the best possible coverage options.

  2. Customer Relationship Management (CRM): CRM platforms help independent agents manage client interactions and track policy renewals, claims, and other important details. This level of organization and efficiency enhances customer service and strengthens client relationships.

  3. Digital Marketing: Independent agencies leverage digital marketing strategies to reach a broader audience and engage with clients online. These digital tools, from social media campaigns to email marketing, help agencies stay connected with clients and prospects.

  4. Telematics and Data Analytics: Telematics and data analytics are providing independent agents with deeper insights into client behavior and risk profiles. This information allows for more accurate underwriting and personalized policy recommendations.

Vantage Point Risk: Embracing the Future of Insurance

At Vantage Point Risk, we are committed to staying at the forefront of industry trends and leveraging technology to serve our clients better. Our approach combines the personalized service and expertise of an independent agency with the efficiencies and capabilities of modern technology. Here are some of the ways we are embracing the future of insurance:

  1. Innovative Quoting Systems: Our advanced quoting systems allow us to quickly compare policies from various carriers, ensuring that our clients receive the best coverage options.

  2. Comprehensive CRM: Our robust CRM platform helps us manage all aspects of client interactions, from policy renewals to claims management. This level of organization ensures we can provide exceptional service and support to our clients.

  3. Digital Engagement: We engage in digital marketing to connect with clients and prospects online. Our social media campaigns, email newsletters, and informative blog posts help us stay connected and provide valuable insights to our audience.

  4. Community Involvement: We believe in giving back to the communities we serve. Our local presence allows us to build strong client relationships and contribute to community initiatives.


The latest Big “I” report highlights independent insurance agencies’ growing importance and impact in the industry. As trusted advisors, independent agents offer personalized service, expert advice, and a wide range of options that clients value. At Vantage Point Risk, we are proud to be part of this thriving community and remain committed to providing our clients with the best possible insurance solutions.

We invite you to learn more about our services and how we can help you find the right coverage for your needs. Contact us today to speak with one of our experienced agents and discover the difference in the Vantage Point Risk.

For more information about our services or to get a quote, visit our website at Vantage Point Risk or call us at 541-681-8793. Stay connected on social media for the latest updates and industry news.

The latest Big “I” report highlights independent insurance agencies’ growing influence and importance in the industry. As trusted advisors, independent agents like those at Vantage Point Risk offer personalized service, expert advice, and a wide range of options that clients highly value. By leveraging modern technology and maintaining a strong community focus, we continue to deliver exceptional insurance solutions. To learn more about the industry’s current trends and insights, you can read the full Big “I” report on the Insurance Journal website.

Read the full article on Insurance Journal