Title: Why Insurance Rates Vary So Much Between Carriers (and Why That’s Okay)
As an independent agency, one of the most common questions we get is: “Why is one insurance company so much cheaper than another for the same coverage?” Sometimes it’s Safeco with the lower rate. Other times, it’s Travelers, Progressive, or even Geico. It depends on a variety of factors—and that variability is a feature, not a flaw, of how insurance pricing works.
A Real-Life Example
We often see scenarios where one carrier’s quote comes in significantly lower than another—sometimes even half the price. This can understandably raise concerns, especially when clients are told by other institutions or representatives, “There’s no way the coverage is the same.”
But more often than not, when we do a side-by-side comparison, the quote with the lower price doesn’t just match the existing policy—it sometimes provides better coverage. For example, a quote might offer higher liability limits, more dwelling protection, or extra endorsements like service line or water backup coverage—all at a lower cost.
This isn’t a fluke. It’s a reflection of how insurance carriers price their policies.
Why Carriers Price Differently
Every insurance company has its own underwriting model. They analyze risk using different formulas, weighing factors like:
-
Property location and condition
-
Credit-based insurance scores
-
Loss history
-
Roof age and material
-
Water source and plumbing type
-
Customer profile and bundling opportunities
What one carrier sees as a “preferred” risk, another might price higher due to internal data or recent loss experiences in that area. These models are also updated frequently, sometimes monthly or quarterly.
Your Bank or Credit Union Isn’t Wrong, They’re Just Limited
In many cases, clients come to us after being told by their bank or credit union (which may also sell insurance) that a competing quote must be missing something. But these institutions typically partner with one or two carriers and may not have access to the broader market.
As an independent agency, we represent you. Our role is to shop multiple carriers to find the best value—not just in price, but in quality of coverage and service.
Price Isn’t Everything, But It Matters
We always encourage our clients to consider more than just price:
-
Are the coverages truly apples-to-apples?
-
Are there valuable endorsements or exclusions?
-
What’s the claims service like?
But when the lower-priced option also offers equal or better coverage, it’s a win.
What to Look for When Reviewing Policies
When comparing insurance policies, it’s essential to look beyond the premium and consider what you’re truly getting. All coverages are important, but some critical components deserve top-level attention:
🔒 Dwelling Coverage (Homeowners Insurance)
This is the foundation of your homeowners’ policy. It should reflect the cost to rebuild your home, not its market value. Too little coverage could leave you exposed to a total loss.
🔒 Liability Coverage
Liability protects your assets if someone is injured on your property or you cause damage to others. We often recommend $300,000 to $500,000, or higher if you have substantial assets.
🔒 Personal Property Coverage
This covers the contents of your home. Ensure the amount is sufficient and understand whether it’s based on replacement cost or actual cash value.
🔒 Loss of Use (Additional Living Expenses)
Covers the cost of living elsewhere if your home becomes uninhabitable due to a covered claim. This can be a financial lifesaver during major repairs.
🔒 Water Backup Coverage
Not always included in standard policies, this protects against damage from backed-up sewers or drains—a common and costly claim.
🔒 Service Line Coverage
Also often optional, this covers underground utility lines you own (like water and electrical lines). Repairs can be expensive without it.
🔒 Deductibles
Ensure you’re comfortable with the deductible amount, especially for perils such as wind or hail, which may have separate terms.
🔒 Endorsements and Exclusions
These tailor the policy to your needs. Look for value-adding endorsements and be aware of exclusions that could limit coverage.
What Happens When You Switch Insurance
When you decide to move to a new insurance policy with better value or coverage, you’ll usually need to cancel your existing policy. This is a simple process, and we’re here to help every step of the way.
🔧 Easy Cancellation Process
If you’re switching policies, we can help you cancel your old one correctly. This ensures that your mortgage company and anyone else who needs to be notified are informed.
Here’s how it works:
-
You tell us you’d like to cancel your current policy.
-
We complete a cancellation form with your information and the preferred end date.
-
You sign the form confirming your intent.
-
We submit it and ensure that all required parties are notified.
📅 Timing Is Key
We coordinate the cancellation so that your new policy starts the same day your old one ends. This keeps you fully covered with no gaps.
💼 Why Sign a Form?
Most insurance companies require written confirmation when you cancel a policy—it protects you and them. The form we use, often referred to as an ACORD 35, is simply a standard industry tool to document this.
What you are doing is submitting a Cancellation Request. This tells your current insurance company, in writing, that you’ve decided to move on. That’s all that’s needed in nearly every case.
Sometimes, people hear the term Policy Release and wonder if they need to sign something extra. A Policy Release is usually only required for more complex situations, like some commercial policies or special types of insurance. For most home and auto policies, especially if you’re switching to a new provider, it’s not needed unless specifically asked for by the company.
📃 Keep It Simple
We’ll walk you through it, and it usually takes just a few minutes. You’ll have a copy for your records, and we’ll make sure it’s appropriately filed.
Final Thoughts
Insurance isn’t one-size-fits-all. What you pay depends on your unique risk profile and how each carrier views it. That’s why being with an independent agency matters—we have options, and we use them to your advantage.
If you’ve been told “that rate can’t be right,” let us take a look. We’ll help you compare with confidence, and back it up with real data—not just assumptions.
